A half-century of by-election upsets

Author: By Chris Mead, Press Association

1958: Mark Bonham-Carter gave the Liberals their first by-election gain
since 1929 when he won Torrington, Devon, from Tories with a 219 majority.
It was a bad year for Conservatives, who lost Rochdale to Labour, coming

1962: Liberal Eric Lubbock, now Lord Avebury, took Orpington off the
Tories on a 26.8% swing.

1966: Gwynfor Evans gave Plaid Cymru its first seat when he took
Carmarthen from Labour on an 18% swing.

1967: Winifred Ewing snatched a seat for the Scottish National Party,
when she turned a 16,576 Labour majority at Hamilton into a 1,799
nationalist one. She polled 46% in a constituency previously uncontested by
her party.

1968: Tories chalked up a 21.1% swing to take Dudley on March 28 from
Labour as well as marginal Meriden and Acton. This was possibly the first
time in history a party lost three seats at by-elections on the same day.

1969: Liberals captured Ladywood, their first Birmingham seat for 83
years, from Labour on a 32% swing. The two years from November 2 1967 to Oct
30 1969 brought Labour its worst by-election run. The party lost 10 seats
during that time and the swing against it was never less than 10%.

1972: Liberals overturned a 12,696 Conservative majority to win Sutton
and Cheam on a 32.6% swing.

1973: Labour defector Dick Taverne won Lincoln for the Democratic
Labour Party, standing against his former party and polling 58.2%. At Ripon
Liberal David Austick gained the seat on a 25.3% swing while Clement Freud
polled 38.3% to win the Isle of Ely for the party – which had not fought the
constituency in the 1970 General Election. The SNP’s Margo MacDonald gained
Glasgow Govan from Labour on a 26.7% swing.

1976: Tories gained Walsall North on a 22.5% swing after the
imprisonment of former Labour minister John Stonehouse.

1977: The Conservatives toppled Labour in its Ashfield mining
stronghold on a 20.8% swing.

1979: David Alton turned a Labour majority of 6,171 in Liverpool Edge
Hill into a Liberal lead of 8,133, achieving a 32.4% swing.

1981: Shirley Williams, a Social Democratic Party founder member, won
Crosby from Tories on a 25.5% swing for the Liberal/SDP Alliance. Liberal
Bill Pitt ousted Conservatives at Croydon North West on a 24.2% swing.

1982: But in the last days of the Falklands War it was Tories’ turn to
win when they took Mitcham and Morden off former Labour MP Bruce
Douglas-Mann who had defected to the SDP, resigned his seat and stood again,
pushing his old party into third place. There was a net 10.2% swing from
Labour to Tories on what was the last occasion the Government party gained
an Opposition seat at a by-election.

1983: Liberal Simon Hughes gained the highest swing since the Second
Word War – 44.2% – when he won Bermondsey from Labour.

1987: Just months from the General Election the SDP’s Rosie Barnes
stormed Labour’s Greenwich, south London, stronghold, winning with a 16.1%

1988: Jim Sillars grabbed Glasgow Govan for the SNP on a 33.1% swing
from Labour, emulating the victory in the same area of his wife Margo
MacDonald 15 years before.

1989: Labour’s John Smith took the Vale of Glamorgan from the Tories on
a 12.4% switch – giving the party its most dramatic by-election win for more
than half a century.

1990: The “safe” Conservative seat of Mid-Staffordshire was won by
Labour with a 21.3% swing. Liberal Democrats ended a run of disappointing
performances when they captured Eastbourne from the Tories on a 20% switch.

1991: Liberal Democrats captured Ribble Valley, among the top 15 Tory
strongholds, by notching up a 24.7% swing after a campaign dominated by the
poll tax. Labour also triumphed two months later winning Monmouth from the
Tories on a 12.6% move. Key issue here was the National Health Service.

1993: The first by-election of the new parliament saw Liberal Democrats
capture Newbury from Tories with 22,055 majority on a 28.4% swing. This was
followed by the Christchurch contest which brought the biggest recorded
swing against a Government – 35.4% from Conservative to Liberal Democrats.

1994: Tories were forced into third place at Eastleigh, where they were
defending a 17,702 majority. Liberal Democrats gained the seat on a 21.4%
swing with a 9,239 majority over Labour. The year ended with Labour scoring
its biggest swing for nearly half a century, 29.1%, to take Dudley West from

1995: Conservatives were forced into third place by Labour as the SNP
took Perth and Kinross off them on an 11.5% swing. Just over a month later
they also tumbled to third position as Liberal Democrats took Littleborough
and Saddleworth on an 11.6% swing.

1996: Tories went down to Labour in another landslide at Staffordshire
South East where the votes movement was 22.2%.

1997: With the General Election less than two months away,
Conservatives lost to Labour at Wirral South on a 17.2% swing. Tories failed
to win a single by-election between William Hague’s victory at Richmond,
Yorks in 1989 and their success in the first contest of the new 1997
Parliament at Uxbridge.

But this success was short-lived when Liberal Democrat Mark Oaten won the
Winchester poll, a re-run after the General Election result was declared
void, with a 21,556 majority on a 19.8% swing.

2000: Liberal Democrats took Romsey, next door constituency to
Winchester, turning an 8,585 Conservative majority into one of 3,311 for
themselves on a 12.56% swing. This was the first time for 35 years that
Tories had lost a seat at a by-election in Great Britain when they were in
Opposition at Westminster.

2003: Labour suffered its first Commons by-election loss since it
returned to power in 1997 when Liberal Democrats snatched Brent East, north
London on a 29% swing.

2004: Liberal Democrats, benefiting from Government unpopularity over
the Iraq war, took another Labour seat at Leicester South on a 21.5% switch.

2006: Labour was rocked again by Liberal Democrats when they gained at
Dunfermline and Fife West, Scotland on a 16.2% swing in the next door
constituency to that of the, then, Chancellor Gordon Brown.

2008: Mr Brown, now Prime Minister, was shaken by Tories’ first Commons
by-election gain in more than a quarter of a century when they took Crewe
and Nantwich on a 17.6% votes turn-round. Two months later Glasgow East
became the second so-called “safe” seat lost by Labour on Mr Brown’s watch.
The switch to the Scottish National Party was 22.5%.

View full article here

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Rating: 0.0/10 (0 votes cast)

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Ezine Article Board


This author has published 5774 articles so far.

Comments are closed